Skip to main content

The door may finally be open for Erik Karlsson's return to Ottawa

After nearly a decade, could former captain Erik Karlsson make a return to Ottawa?
ByAlicia Racine
Former Ottawa Senators captain, Erik Karlsson
Former Ottawa Senators captain, Erik Karlsson | Andre Ringuette/GettyImages

It’s been almost 3,000 days since former general manager Pierre Dorion rocked the fan base and traded Erik Karlsson away to the San Jose Sharks. Although it stung at the time, this trade ended up being a cornerstone trade for the team as it turned into the Ottawa Senators drafting their franchise centre, Tim Stützle.

Erik Karlsson, Doug Wilson, Peter DeBoer
Erik Karlsson First Sharks Practice and Press Event | Brandon Magnus/GettyImages

Despite the trade leaving the Senators in a better position years after the trade, hardly any Senators fans wanted to see their former captain and three-time Norris Trophy winner leave. Since his departure in September 2018, the possibility of Karlsson returning to Ottawa has been a hot topic of conversation among Senators fans. With the Swedish defenceman entering the final season of his contract with the Pittsburgh Penguins and the Senators off to one of their most impressive starts, a reunion may be on the horizon. 

Although the talks of a trade bring back lots of nostalgic feelings for Senators fans, sometimes, where there is smoke, there is fire. Ottawa reportedly explored the option of bringing King Karl back during the 2022-2023 season, but management was concerned about bringing back a former captain so soon into Brady Tkachuk’s captaincy. There were talks of the Senators wanting to avoid a clash between leadership in the dressing room and Tkachuk being undermined. 

Reporter Bruce Garrioch noted that since Tkachuk’s departure, this narrative has changed. Captain Thomas Chabot would embrace a trade bringing his former mentor and teammate back. As Chabot is still early in his captaincy, he could learn from Karlsson, who wore the C in the nation’s capital for four seasons. 

Thomas Chabot, Nick Cousins
Captain Thomas Chabot and teammate Nick Cousins | Troy Parla/GettyImages

Do the Senators actually need him?

When we look at the Senators roster, we see that they already have some players that bring what the 36-year-old would. They have talented offensive defensemen in Jake Sanderson, Thomas Chabot and Jordan Spence. With that in mind, adding another experienced, right-shot offensive defenseman could boost them from a playoff team to a Stanley Cup contender. 

What’s very enticing is that Karlsson clearly still has it. The defenceman leads the Penguins in assists and points with 16 and 19, respectively. Through 20 games, he has 19 points, and the Senators could use this offensive power on their blue line. Interestingly enough, 8 of his points come on the power play, an area that the Senators continue to struggle with. I think power-play units quarterbacked by Sanderson and Karlsson would be huge for the team. 

Of course, acquiring a Norris Trophy winner wouldn’t be straightforward or cheap. With a $10 million cap hit, salary retention or a salary-clearing move would need to happen to make it work. But at what cost for the Senators? Should Ottawa offer a package including blue-chip prospect and promising young defenceman Carter Yakemchuk? Although he’s valuable to the Senators, he’s been spending more time in the press box than on the ice as of late.

Could the Senators make it work?

We armchair general managers could draw up many possible trade packages, but the question that looms is whether or not Karlsson would actually want to come back to Ottawa. 

Karlsson has continued to have strong ties to the Ottawa community. He and his family spend their off-season here, his wife is from Ottawa, and they love the town. One of the only stingers is that Karlsson’s friend and mentor, Daniel Alfredsson, left the Senators organization and is now with the Toronto Maple Leafs. If Karlsson wants to come back to Canada, would it be more appealing to go with his former teammate? With a full no-movement clause, Karlsson holds all the cards. 

Daniel Alfredsson, Erik Karlsson
Former Senators teammates and friends, Daniel Alfredsson and Erik Karlsson | Jana Chytilova/Freestyle Photo/GettyImages

Despite the Alfredsson connection, Ottawa is superior in almost all other areas. Not only is it a familiar environment, but the Senators are trending in a far better direction than the Maple Leafs. Karlsson could have a legitimate opportunity to compete for a Stanley Cup with the Senators, who sit at the top of the Atlantic Division, and that could certainly be appealing 

I’m not saying the trade is going to happen. But at the right price, the Senators would be silly to turn down his experience, his offensive production and his familiarity with the organization. This wouldn’t be just a nostalgic move; it would be a Cup-contender decision.

Add us as a preferred source on Google