1. Craig Anderson
When asked who the best goaltender is in Senators history, it's without a doubt Craig Anderson. The Senators were searching for a goaltender to be their new number one, and they found it when they traded for Anderson from the Colorado Avalanche midway through the 2010-11 season.
Once Anderson was traded to the Senators, Anderson would be a big part of helping the Senators have success for a decade. The Senators made the playoffs in 2012, 2013, 2015 and 2017.
Anderson has the most wins (202), saves (12,477) and minutes (24,840). Anderson is also second in shutouts with 28. Anderson went 202-168-46 in 435 games played, 2.84 goals against average and a .914 save percentage. Anderson also won the 2017 Masterton and was fourth in Vezina Trophy voting in 2013.
Without Anderson, the Senators wouldn't have seen success in the 2010s. Anderson is the number one Senator that needs to be inducted in the Senators Ring of Honour.