Patrick Marleau, San Jose Sharks
Marleau finished third in the balloting for this award back in 2006. He was assessed 18 penalty minutes while amassing 70 points. He was also credited with 85 hits and 50 takeaways. Among his penalties, 4 were tripping and 2 were hooking. He did not have a single roughing or slashing infraction and had a lone high-sticking call.