Jesse Winchester or Zack Smith?

The two-year veteran with lots still to prove

If you look at the cap space Bryan Murray has to manage around for the rest of this un-eventful off-season, it’s clear no more moves will be made unless somebody is shipped out for a prospect or draft pick. With training camp coming, the real battle up front should be to centre Nick Foligno and Ryan Shannon and the third line.

Click “Continue Reading” to find out who should win the third-line centre job on Opening Night, either Jesse Winchester or Zack Smith.


The war is between two people who play very similar styles of play. Jesse Winchester, the undrafted forward out of Colgate was seen as a premier coup for Murray two years ago, but now is nothing more than a depth player. Winchester does the little things right, he forechecks hard, creates space for his line-mates, and is excellent on the boards. A poor man’s Peter Schaefer (is that even possible?) in my opinion. Zack Smith is all that and more. He’s young, fast, and a tough cookie. He stands up for the team and can fight the best of the best in the league.

Both are major assets on special team, specifically the penalty kill. Jesse has had more time in a Cory Clouston system than Zack has had, but you can argue that Smith also played under Triple C in Binghamton. Zack has the upper hand for me because he’s faster and cheaper for management. However, I can see both fighting ’till the last minute for the job.

Winchie has scored 5 goals and 31 points in his career during two seasons. Although being injury-riddled last season including one at camp, I see more opportunities for him on this team than he would get on any other team, basically meaning there is no market for Jesse.

Lunchpail Zack has a knack for big-time plays, including this one below which started off his young career in terms of production:

So who will start on October 8th against the Buffalo Sabres? Well, it’s hard to tell now, but I truly believe Cloo Cloo believes more in Smith than Winchester, especially after a great playoffs he had last season. If there’s one thing we know, watch out ’cause either of these two should have a break-out season.

 You can follow SenShot at its Facebook Page, on Twitter and sign up with SenShot on Android for your phone.

Tags: Battles Bryan Murray Forward Jesse Winchester Paul MacLean Peter Schaefer Training Camp 2010 Zack Smith

  • Todd MacDonald

    Zack Smith hands down got the spot as 3rd line center…. Oh and winchester beats Shannon out for the 3rd line right winger easily. (And if he doesn’t Wick or Butler will beat him out, Shannon is a last resort nobody else to call up filler)

  • GelatinousMutantCoconut

    What Todd said.

    It’s not really one or the other unless one of the rookies (Wick, Butler, Hoffman, Daugavins, Condra, Caporusso, Cowick) really impresses in camp. Put them both with Foligno and you have a decent to solid bottom-6 line.